AI Startups Are Hiring for Speed. The Ones That Last Hire for Evolution.
Every hiring manager I talk to has the same problem right now. The resume in front of them describes a job that may not exist in six months.
The interview question everyone has added, “How do you use AI?”, doesn’t help much either. Tools change monthly. What someone can do with today’s model tells you very little about how they’ll behave when the ground shifts under them for the third time this quarter.
The fastest-growing AI companies have figured out part of the answer. They’ve stopped screening hard for expertise and started screening for soft skills like agency and a bias toward shipping today instead of next week.
I think they’re half right.
Almost every trait on those lists points to one thing, the ability to adapt. That matters enormously. But a team that only adapts fast will happily move fast in the wrong direction. AI makes it cheaper than ever to cut a corner, automate a person out of the loop, or ship something that technically works and quietly erodes customer trust.
Speed without ethics and empathy is how companies grow quickly and then stall. I’ve watched it happen more than once.
Why an Evolutionary Mindset Is the Better Filter
In Evolve for Growth, I lay out what evolutionary science tells us about the entities that thrive. Whether it’s a person, a team, or a company, the ones with an evolutionary mindset tend to innovate more and last longer.
They share four traits. They focus on the greater good. They have high emotional intelligence and empathy. They’re adaptable, with a habit of testing, reflecting, and adjusting. And they have conceptual intelligence, the ability to frame problems creatively and add real value.
In leadership terms, these are the people who move past survivor ethics and into what I call the Evolutionary Zone. In hiring terms, they’re the people who stay valuable after the job you hired them for has changed shape.
Here’s how I screen for each one.
1. A Focus on the Greater Good
AI hands everyone more power to act, and fewer people stop to ask who gets hurt. Someone who uses that power only for personal wins becomes a liability the moment the shortcut lands on a customer.
The question I ask
“Tell me about a time you decided not to use AI for something, or limited how you used it, because of the effect on a customer or a colleague.”
What I’m listening for
A real example with a real tradeoff. I want to hear them weigh what was fast against what was right, and land somewhere thoughtful. Bonus points if they can explain how the decision served the team or the company, not just themselves.
The red flag
They can’t think of one, or they treat the question as naive. Low moral intelligence shows up as decisions made without considering anyone outside the immediate goal.
2. Emotional Intelligence and Empathy
AI agents can handle tasks. People still handle trust. Every time someone automates part of a workflow, they change another person’s job. The builder who rolls that out without bringing people along creates resistance and rework that wipes out the time saved.
The question I ask
“When you automated or changed part of a workflow, how did you bring along the people whose work was affected?”
What I’m listening for
Whether they talked to those people before and after. Whether they noticed how the change landed. Whether they describe colleagues with curiosity rather than frustration. Self-awareness and social awareness show up in the details of the story.
The red flag
People appear only as obstacles. “They just didn’t get it.” Coldness, tactlessness, or a story in which they are the only hero tells you how they’ll treat your team.
3. Adaptability
This is where the AI startup frameworks are strongest, and I agree with them. Working with AI is a constant cycle of breakthroughs and dead ends. A tool does something astonishing on Tuesday and fails at something simple on Wednesday.
In the book I describe adaptability as a loop. Test, reflect, adjust, and repeat. It overlaps with what Carol Dweck calls a growth mindset, the belief that effort changes what you’re capable of.
The question I ask
“What’s something you had to try several different ways before it worked?”
What I’m listening for
How many attempts they made and what they learned between them. A story about the fifth try tells me more than a story about instant success.
The red flag
One try, then a verdict that “AI just isn’t good at that.” Rigidity, defending how things have always been done, or offering opinions where results should be.
4. Conceptual Intelligence and Creative Thinking
AI can generate a hundred answers in seconds. It can’t imagine what should exist that doesn’t yet. Innovation still starts with a person who sees a possibility nobody else has framed.
Conceptual intelligence is the ability to visualize possibilities and turn them into something that adds value. At the low end is purely operational thinking. That person executes each step well but struggles to picture a different way of working.
The question I ask
“Picture your role two years from now. How do you see AI changing the way this work gets done, and what would you want to try first?”
What I’m listening for
Original thinking, not a list of tasks AI will automate. The strongest answers reimagine the work itself. They borrow ideas from other fields and describe new value for customers or the business.
I also want to hear a first step. Someone who can sketch the bigger picture and then tell me how they’d test it is showing conceptual intelligence in action.
The red flag
Generic answers lifted from headlines. “AI will handle the busywork so I can focus on strategy” tells me they haven’t really thought about it. So does a vision that amounts to doing today’s job slightly faster.
Keep Evaluating After the Offer
Even a well-designed interview misses things. Candidates prepare, and good storytellers can sound evolutionary for an hour.
So I treat the probation period, usually around 90 days, as a continuation of the screen. Assign someone on the team with a strong evolutionary mindset to observe the new hire, gather feedback from the people they work with, and assess them on these four traits. Train hiring managers to do the same.
In the AI era, the gap between how someone interviews and how they actually work shows up fast. Use that. Treat evolutionary fit as something you measure, with the same seriousness as job skills.
Fast in a Direction Worth Going
When I helped Zuper build its culture code after its $20 million raise, we designed the screening questions around these same ideas, from empathy and a growth mindset to customer obsession and a focus on results. The biggest lesson was that getting the employee DNA right has to start at the very first interview.
The companies that win the AI era won’t simply be the fastest. They’ll be the ones moving fast in a direction worth going, with people who care where that is.
If you want to go deeper, the hiring chapter of my book Evolve for Growth walks through the full approach, including more of the interview questions I use to screen for an evolutionary mindset.